Common Autograph Collecting Mistakes

Every collector makes mistakes — but you don't have to learn the hard way. Here are the most common errors new autograph collectors make and how to avoid them.

• •Buying unauthenticated items from unknown sellers
• •Trusting generic COAs from unknown companies
• •Paying retail prices without comparison shopping
• •Not verifying hologram sticker numbers in online databases
• •Assuming all items from major retailers are authentic

• •Getting items personalized ("To John") — reduces resale value
• •Using the wrong pen for the surface (Sharpie on a puck = invisible)
• •Not protecting items immediately after signing
• •Overcrowding a single item with too many signatures
• •Focusing only on value instead of personal enjoyment

• •Displaying signed items in direct sunlight (UV fading)
• •Using non-acid-free materials for storage
• •Stacking signed photos without protection between them
• •Storing items in attics or basements (temperature/humidity extremes)
• •Not insuring valuable pieces against damage or theft

• •Selling during market dips or off-season when demand is low
• •Not authenticating before selling (reduces sale price significantly)
• •Using the wrong platform for your item type
• •Setting unrealistic reserve prices at auction
• •Accepting lowball offers without researching fair market value

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Guides