Autographs 101 · Collector guide

Is a COA legit? How to check a certificate of authenticity

From the Autographs 101 Facebook group: 52,000 collectors comparing notes since 2012.

Start with who issued it

Anyone can print a certificate. The first question is whether the company is one you can look up, with its own website and a public lookup for its numbers.

Large third party companies such as PSA/DNA, JSA and Beckett have public lookups. Many sellers also write their own certificates, which tell you what the seller claims rather than what an outside company reviewed.

COA, in the glossary

PSA vs JSA vs Beckett

Look the number up yourself

Type the number from the sticker or letter into the issuer's own lookup page. Do not rely on a link or screenshot from the seller.

Compare the signer, the item type and any photo in the record with your piece. A number that belongs to a different item is a serious warning sign.

All certificate lookups

How to look up a certificate number

Warning signs on a COA

No number, no company address or website, a number that does not appear in any lookup, or a certificate that describes a different item.

A dealer certificate with a lifetime promise is still only the dealer's word. Weigh it against the dealer's history and return policy.

Autograph scams to avoid

Holograms and stickers

A hologram sticker links the item to a record. It helps only if the sticker is on the item it was issued for and the record matches. Stickers can be peeled and moved, so check for damage around them.

Event and team holograms, such as those from leagues and memorabilia companies, have their own lookups too.

Hologram stickers, in the glossary

What to do next

If the COA does not hold up, you can still research the signature itself and the seller's history, or ask an established company for an opinion.

Pre-Screen can give you a second look from a photo and point out what to compare next.

Run a free Pre-Screen

Red flags to check before you buy

Frequently asked questions

Does a COA mean an autograph is real?

No. A COA is the issuer's opinion or claim. How much it helps depends on who issued it and whether it matches your item.

How do I check if a COA is legit?

Find the issuer, open their own website and lookup page, type the number and compare the record with your item.

Is a seller's own COA worth anything?

It records what the seller claims. It can matter for a return, but it is not an outside review.

Turn a useful answer into research you can keep.

Preview the steps free. Gold and Emerald members can save a personalized playbook, add private notes and resume it through Research Shelf.

Before-you-buy review

Keep the questions, missing evidence and your own purchase limits in one place.

  1. Record the exact item, claimed signer and version being offered.
  2. Request whole-item photos, a sharp signature close-up and condition details.
  3. Separate the seller's claims from supporting signing or acquisition records.
  4. Record the price, shipping, fees and your own maximum total budget.
  5. Write down unresolved questions before deciding whether to proceed.
Certificate research file

Keep the claimed issuer, item comparison and unresolved mismatches together.

  1. Identify the claimed issuer from the label or certificate.
  2. Find the issuer's official lookup or support channel independently.
  3. Compare the issuer record, item description, label and actual piece.
  4. Record mismatches or missing information without treating a number match as authentication.
  5. Keep your questions and any response date for the next review.
Comparable-sales research

Build a repeatable record of relevant sold examples instead of relying on asking prices.

  1. Define the exact item type, signer, version and condition you are researching.
  2. Record a completed sale's source, date, currency and available price details.
  3. Note differences in authentication, inscriptions, condition and item type.
  4. Keep asking prices and unconfirmed sales separate from completed-sale evidence.
  5. Describe the limits of your comparison; do not turn a few examples into a guaranteed value.
Collection documentation plan

Organize a piece's history and the records you still need to gather.

  1. Describe a piece you own and its identifying details.
  2. List the photos, receipts and supporting records you have.
  3. Separate documented acquisition history from recollection or seller claims.
  4. Record condition observations and where supporting files are kept.
  5. Choose what to add to your private Vault after reviewing the information.
Piece provenance review

Organize the evidence behind one signed piece, identify the gaps, and decide which record to check next.

  1. Give the piece a name specific enough to recognize later.
  2. List the records you have reviewed, including sources and dates.
  3. Separate someone’s account of the signing or acquisition from the records you can check.
  4. Record what is missing or what does not match.
  5. Choose the next check and a date to revisit it.

Enable JavaScript to fill and copy the free piece provenance worksheet. The other interactive workspaces require a free account. Gold and Emerald add saving and updating across devices. Playbooks share the existing Research Shelf allowance: Gold 25 plans; Emerald 100.

A completed checklist is a research aid you can keep with the piece. Previewing does not save a record, start a scan or charge you.